Archive | 2006

DAN! Protocol For Dummies

20 Mar

Whenever anyone else hears the word ‘DAN!’ with that little exclamation mark do they go ‘DAN! – DAN! – DAN – DAN!’ to the opening four bars of the theme to ‘Dragnet’? No? Ah well, just me then.

Ken Aitken is a psychologist. He’s also a DAN! Doctor. One doesn’t need to be an actual Doctor to be a DAN! Doctor apparently:

As for choosing a DAN!, it just depends on what type of treatment you are looking for. DAN!’s that are MDs or DOs are typically going to be much more into testing and genetics and lots of expensive and invasive stuff. This, of course, is a gross generalization and isn’t necessarily true of all DAN! MDs, but rather something to be cautious of. A DAN! who is a homeopath or naturopath is typically going to do things more naturally and less invasive. Again, it’s a generalization. There are chiropractors, allergists and other types of doctors that are DAN!s as well, so it is really the type of doctor and treatment that best suits your needs. Many people go with a MD or DO because they can get insurance coverage for some of the services.

Homeopaths and Naturopaths doing things ‘naturally’. Heh. Does this lack of training in medical matters prevent them from performing things like chelation (source as above)?

…which is why we went with a homeopath/naturopath…….We decided to get the mercury out because I knew that Seth had had way too much put into him and it wasn’t coming out at all (he’s a non-excretor).

Homeopaths and Naturopaths doing chelation. Cool.

I talked to one yesterday (a DAN doctor mind you) and how he got qualifications to be one is beyond me. He told me has a couple of autistic patients and knows of the chelation process. If this is all that is required to be a DAN doctor then I don’t see a distinct advantage to them either.

Source.

Is your mind boggling yet? Here’s the reply to this commenter (source as above):

I think that being on the DAN list (in the past) meant something like that the person had attended some DAN training– or something rather general like this. Someone (in some post, somewhere) who went to the recent DAN conference wrote about that there is/was some discussion afoot to try to improve on this and make the
info on doctors more useful (or more detailed….or something??)

This doesn’t sound like a recipie for disaster at all. Was Roy Kerry a DAN! Doctor? I don’t know.

I came across some priceless websites pushing the DAN! protocol. They had numerous things in common, chiefly the disclaimer – all variations on the theme of:

this is not medical advice

Which is odd because from that point on, they mostly plough into what can only be thought of as _advice_ about what _medication_ an autistic child should take. There’s a fairly representative sample of what a dutiful DAN! Doc should do on the website of Miriam Jang MD. First, the usual copout from responsibility:

At this point, I would like to point out that this is not medical advice, even though I am a Medical Doctor. Rather, this is a wish for your child or your loved one(s) to have the advantage of what took us eight years to discover. Please take this as a medical disclaimer. All suggestions here should be done at your own risk.

‘Own risk’. Right. Or actually – wrong. She means the risk of the child receiving the treatment. Thats whos health will suffer when if it all goes wrong.

Dr Jang decides to lead off with some impressive science:

In both Chinese medicine and Ayurvedic medicine, the sages believed that there were only two ways to health: one was to correct deficiencies; the other was to get rid of toxicities.

Ayurvedic? What the hell?

This ancient art of healing has been practiced continuously for over 5,000 years. The principles of many natural healing systems now familiar in the West, such as Homeopathy and Polarity Therapy, have their roots in Ayurveda. Ayurvedic practices restore the balance and harmony of the individual, resulting in self-healing, good health and longevity.

So, DAN! Doctors are homeopaths and naturopaths who practice er, Polarity Therapy. Polarity Therapy? What the hell?

Polarity Therapy is a comprehensive health system involving energy-based bodywork, diet, exercise and self-awareness. It works with the Human Energy Field, electromagnetic patterns expressed in mental, emotional and physical experience.

Riiiight. OK. Back to er, Doctor (?) Jang. Basically, there’s a load of stuff with no cites – such as:

An important finding is that about 85 percent of Autistic kids are high in Copper and low in Zinc. Furthermore, these kids are very low in an important protein call Metallothionein, or MT Protein.

Hmm. Searching PubMed for ‘Metallothionein autism’ reveals two results. One is an inaccessible review and one is a free PDF published in the confidence inspiringly named ‘Alternative Medecine Review’. A Google search for the same reveals the predicted circus of quackery.

Except….another one of the mercury/autism darlings, Vijendra K. Singh has a paper that states:

serum level of MT did not significantly differ between normal and autistic children. Furthermore, autistic children harboured normal levels of anti-MT, including antibodies to isoform MT-I (anti-MT-I) and MT-II (anti-MT-II), without any significant difference between normal and autistic children.

A dilema, no? (You can read more on this paper here.)

Dr Jang continues with:

I will include a list of supplements that Marky is taking. There are many protocols, with many rationales. When we write down the dosages, please take into consideration that Marky is 11 years old and weighs 75 pounds. Please adjust your dosages according to your child’s weight.

Marky is her son. But isn’t it amazing how a DAN! Doctor is assuming parents know *how* to adjust medications for weight – and is happy to trust them to do so without medical supervision or even consultation!

Towards the end of her piece she says:

Please remember that, if you introduce your child to a new supplement, it is not unusual for the child to experience some adverse effects for a short while…When this happens, it does not necessarily mean that you should discontinue the supplement, unless the adverse effects are dangerous, or persistent….If there are adverse effects, stay at this dose until the adverse effects are gone, then proceed to a slightly higher dose, etc.

So there may be adverse effects but don’t stop unless the adverse effects are dangerous, instead stay on the same dose until the adverse effects are gone. I can’t imagine any Doctor thinking this is good advice. Interestingly, the following appeared from Dr Jang as part of an email newsletter:

I would like to start with some very serious news: we do have to be careful of Vitamin A toxicity with our sweet kids. There is a child with reported Vitamin A toxicity that was so severe that the child had to be hospitalized for 12 days.

Her patient? I wonder. Maybe the practitioner (whomever s/he was) read her advice to ‘stay on the same dose until the adverse effects are gone’.

Dr Jang tells us in relation to supplements that:

We noticed a difference in Marky in less than a week.

And yet later on she says:

In addition, you may not see the beneficial effects of these supplements for a period of time.

Something of a glaring contradiction. Which is true?

Anyway, having expounded all this good advice, Dr Jang closes with:

So, be curious and be persistent. Take good care of yourselves so that you can endure this arduous journey called “Autism”!

Yes, be curious – try everything that takes your fancy. Be persistent – whats a little Vitamin A poisoning between friends? And above all take good care of _yourselves_ so that _you_ can endure this journey…..except, its not _you_ who’s undergoing all these treatments is it? Its your child.

Dr Jang is also a big clay bath fancier (clay baths cure autism? Who knew?)

“…I have put a huge number of patients on these clay baths and the levels of heavy metals – mercury, lead, arsenic, aluminum, and cadmium have come down dramatically…I have been monitoring the levels of metals using all three methods (TD DMPS, oral DMSA and clay baths)and the clay baths are way faster in the removal of metals”.

Hoooo boy! Rashid’s going to be plenty pissed with her. Better than TD DMPS? Surely not! Why not use both? Smother your child with TD DMPS and then wash that stuff off in a nice clay bath? At least your child will have a nice happy splash in a bath.

So, Ken Aitken – welcome to your new role as a Dan! Doctor. I feel sure you can uphold the strong scientific standards your colleagues demonstrate.

Lupron: An Alternate View

17 Mar

I think it was Prometheus who first used the phrase:

You can’t reason someone out of a belief they haven’t reasoned themselves into.

By which he meant that proponents of the mercury/autism hypothesis were acting out of belief, innuendo and poor science rather than scientifically valid science and that subsequently trying to use reason to dissect their arguments was of limited use.

What I intend to do in the rest of this post is use the tactics, sources and methods commonly used by proponents of the autism/mercury connection to justify their belief systems. before I do I want to assure you that _nothing_ in this post is fabricated.

As we all know, Lupron has been big news recently. The Geiers love it, the mercury/autism crowd are clamouring to use it and the likes of Orac, Kathleen, Autism Diva, Prometheus and myself have all blogged comprehensively against its use.

However, we were using science and reason and as we know, there are people who are impervious to these things. However, when I received a fascinating email from a middle aged American woman who wanted to talk to me about Lupron I read her words with interest. As all proponents of the mercury/autism hypothesis know, anecdotes trump science. With that in mind I read her opening statement.

I am extremely concerned about the use of the drug Lupron being used on autistic children. As a former consumer of this drug, I can tell you firsthand how harmful it is. I understand the desperation people may experience trying to do all they can to heal their conditions, but we must not forget that Lupron is actually chemotherapy, and leaves the same conditions other forms of chemo do on patients. You wouldn’t give chemo to someone who didn’t have cancer, so how Lupron made the jump to all these other patient groups is purely manufactured by Abbott Labs, the parent of TAP who makes Lupron.

Lupron is chemotherapy. Lupron is manufactured by Big Pharma’s TAP – owned by Abbot Labs. A little digging on the Internet turns up lots of bad things about Abbot Labs:

ABBOTT LABS OBESITY DRUG KILLS 32 PEOPLE AND IS PULLED OFF THE MARKET IN ITALY

Source.

Abbott Laboratories, the world’s 12th largest drug company, has been suspended for a minimum of six months from membership in the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI).

Source

If there was ever any reason to squash human beings like a bug, the decision makers at Abbott Labortories have provided a perfect one with their decision to increase the cost of the anti-AIDS drug Norvir by 500% (from $1500 to $7800 per year).

Source.

Thats just the tip of the iceberg. My anonymous emailer continued….

Any child already harmed by vaccinations does not deserve a second pharmaceutical insult, which is what Lupron will
do. TAP/Abbott is a filthy company, and thinks nothing about the harm they do to patients. It was just published how 800 people have died from another drug they make.

Pretty convincing stuff, I think you’ll agree. Its obvious that Lupron is manufactured by the same sort of bottom-feeding evil scum Big Pharma types that inject autism-causing thiomersal into healthy babies. My anonymous emailer continued:

It just horrorfied me to read about these kids being encouraged to take this drug. Do you know, there was a National Lupron Victims Network with over 2 million hits that suddenly just disappeared off the net? The data is on Way Back Machine or Archive.org under “lupronvictims.com”. We have Abbott employees who follow us around the internet trying to discredit us. It’s like science fiction.

So I checked it out – the domain ‘lupronvictims.com’ was registered in August of 1999 and is hosted by Forest a Seattle company – the same city that the domain registrant specified. I’ve sent an email to the admin contact at Forest to enquire about why the site vanished in early 2005 but have thus far recieved no reply.

As proponents of the Simpsonwood conspiracy will readily recognise, this reeks of corruption and Big Pharma meddling.

The site is indeed archived on the WayBack Machine but fascinatingly, even though the Way Back Machine continued to archive up until March 2005, one has to go back to late 2003 to find actual archived content. the most complete archive is the first one from 1999.

And still my anonymous emailer had more to say:

Whether this happens to all patients I don’t know, but I do know there are many, many people living in hell from using it. Some of us have contracted terrible deseases from having our immune system compromised, and we all battle many diseases: CFS, Fibromyalgia, EBV, arthritus, severe memory problems, clinical depression, liver problems, high cholesterol, trabecular bone loss creating disc herniation and osteoporosis, etc.

She also mentioned the name ‘Lynne Millican’:

In 1999 I went public in the Boston Herald with my story trying to prevent more poisonings. One person, Lynne Millican, has testified before the senate. We have fought and fought to bring awareness to no avail.

A quick search reveals some impressive sources:

When we first met Lynne Millican in January, when this series on Lupron was launched, we learned that she still suffers a range of serious ailments more than a decade after injections of the drug, Lupron, for treatment of endometriosis. Millican, a registered nurse and paralegal, believes her problems are associated with Lupron. Millican’s numerous symptoms have included the development of a noncancerous tumor, breast cysts, cardiac arrythmias, pain, dizziness, swelling and fatigue. She is one of many women treated for endometriosis who have complained over the years about these and other lingering symptoms they believe are related to Lupron. Other symptoms include depression and confusion, bone pain, vision loss, high blood pressure, and nausea.

Red Flags Weekly

“There are thousands in the United States who say they have been victimized by this drug,” Millican said, emphasizing that symptoms can be severe, such as tremors, seizures and memory loss. “Many women I know say their symptoms didn’t stop when they stopped taking the drug.”

Mercola

Proof indeed. My anonymous emailer closed with the following:

They just got bagged doing the same dirty tricks in England that they were levied the largest fine in US History for doing
here. They have so much money they just pay everyone off. Get the word out. Prevent more poisonings because the FDA does not care.

I think supporters of the thiomeral/autism connection will testify to the truth of that. The FDA are in the pocket of Abbot Labs, Big Pharma Agents of the Apocolypse.

Truly, its stupid to put Lupron into kids. When their bodies start to break down, we can all march on Washington – the placards will read ‘It was the Lupron, stupid’.

No need for science. No need for investigation. As a regualr commenter here says ‘Because its obvious…’

Creating A Dynamic OPML File

17 Mar

When I created Autism Hub I wanted to give its users as many options as possible. Obviously, rolling my own RSS feed was a priority but I also wanted to create an OPML file for people to import all the blog details straight into their readers.

Its an easy process – first declare the structure of your OPML file:

$top= "n"
      . "n"
      . "n"
      . "autismhub.opmln"
      . "" . date("D, j M Y H:i:s") . "n"
      . "Kevin Leitchn"
      . "admin@autism-hub.co.ukn"
      . "n"
      . "n";

$bottom = "n"
      . "";

$data = "";

$data will be used to build up our feed details. Again, this is easy. I have a database table which contains all my feed details. All you need to do is connect to this table in the usual way and loop through like so:

if ($row = mysql_fetch_array($sql)) {
  do {	
   $blogurl = $row['blogurl'];
   $feedurl = $row['feedurl'];	
   $name = htmlentities($row['name'], ENT_QUOTES);			
   $data .= "n";
  }
 while ($row = mysql_fetch_array($sql));	
}
$all = $top . $data . $bottom;

Now, all you need to do is check for the presence of a file called autismhub.opml and if it exists, empty it of data and write new all the data to it. If it doesn’t exist, create it and then append all the data into it.

$file = "autismhub.opml";   
if (!$file_handle = fopen($file,"w+")) { echo "Cannot open file"; }  
if (!fwrite($file_handle, $all)) { echo "Cannot write to file"; }  
fclose($file_handle);  

$filename = "/path/to/file/autismhub.opml";
$filename = realpath($filename);

if (!file_exists($filename)) {
 die("NO FILE HERE");
}

and finally, present this compiled file as a download:

header("Pragma: public");
header("Expires: 0");
header("Cache-Control: must-revalidate, post-check=0, pre-check=0");
header("Cache-Control: private",false);
header("Content-Type: application/octet-stream");
header("Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="".basename($filename)."";");
header("Content-Transfer-Encoding: binary");
header("Content-Length: ".@filesize($filename));
set_time_limit(0);
@readfile("$filename") or die("File not found.");

You can get all the code here.

DOM/AJAX/PHP File Browser

17 Mar

Time for a change of pace.

Recently, the HR Dept where I work, approached me as they wanted to be able to update their section of the company Intranet as easily as possible. After looking at their requirements it became clear that what they needed was an area where they could replace old files with new versions of the same file, or add new directories/files, or edit existing directory/file names. Practically, this was easy – they had write access to the main HR directory on the Intranet so it would be a simple case of them dragging and dropping files/directories from their local drives to the HR directory on the Intranet.

The technical challenge for me came from the subsequent need to create a ‘HR file browser’ which would allow all company Intranet users to browse this directory and download selected files in a usable, aesthetically pleasing manner i.e. not just hardlink to the directory and allow them to browse a list of directories.

The obvious answer was to create a DOM driven file browser that would pick up file/directory data from a PHP script. However, I must allow for users that might’ve disabled Javascript or who hadn’t got a certain feature set (getElementById etc).

The script would have four main components:

1) A markup file that contained the actual page and file browser
2) A CSS file to style the elements on this page
3) A Javascript file to manipulate the behaviour of these files
4) A PHP file to read and control access to files and directories

The PHP File

This file contains the ‘guts’ of the webapp. It must be able to:

a) Allow a directory to be defined which is the ‘base’ of the application i.e. the main HR directory in my case. Users should not be able to browse above this base.
b) Get a list of all directories and files within the current directory.
c) Get the file extension of every file so I can dynamically apply a class name and hence style for each file type.
d) Allow a reverse path to be built to display the current path and to build a working ‘back’ button.
e) Make all displayed directories browsable and all displayed files downloadable.
f) It must work and be usable even if the user does not have Javascript/requisite DOM capabilities.
g) Disregard the files that drive this app.

I was lucky enough to already know of the existence of a PHP script that did approx 60% of the work I needed it to so I set about cannibalising and rebuilding this script, taking out the bits I didn’t need and writing in bits I did need. The script as it stood met requirements a), b) and e) so I needed to work on refining those areas and adding in new bits. I won’t go through the whole thing but I do want to discuss certain aspects of it:

Getting the file extension is not difficult:

function get_extension($Filename) {
   $Extension = explode (".", $Filename);
   $Extension_i = (count($Extension) - 1);
   return $Extension[$Extension_i];
}

And neither is reversing the path:

function reverse_strrchr($haystack, $needle){
   $pos = strrpos($haystack, $needle);
   if($pos === false) {
       return $haystack;
   }
   return substr($haystack, 0, $pos);
}

I also had to split the foreach blocks in two as I wanted to rpesent the directories first, then the files – directories have a set style whereas files have a style dependant on their file extension:

echo "<ul>
foreach ($file_array as $file_name) {
      $is_file = DOWNLOAD_PATH . "/$final_path/$file_name";
      if (is_dir($is_file) &amp;&amp; $file_name != "browser-images") {
        print " <li><a class='dir' href='" . $_SERVER&#91;"PHP_SELF"&#93; . "?go=list&amp;
               path=" . urlencode($final_path) . "/" . urlencode($file_name) . "'>" 
               . $file_name . "</a></li>n";
      }
}
echo "</ul>";

echo "<ul id='filepath'>n";
foreach ($file_array as $file_name) {
  $is_file = DOWNLOAD_PATH . "/$final_path/$file_name";				
  if (is_file($is_file) &amp;&amp; $file_name != "browser.php") {
    if(get_extension($file_name) == "css"){
      $ext = "code";
    }else if(get_extension($file_name) == "php"){
      $ext = "php";
    }
   
   ....

   }				
   print " <li><a class='" . $ext . "' href='" .  $_SERVER&#91;"PHP_SELF"&#93; . "?
           go=download&amp;path=" . urlencode($final_path) . "&amp;file="
           . urlencode($file_name) . "'>" . $file_name . "</a></li>n";
 }
		
}
echo "</ul>n";

You might also notice these lines:

if (is_dir($is_file) && $file_name != "browser-images") {

...

if (is_file($is_file) && $file_name != "browser.php"

This tells the script to disregard the file if the directory name is ‘browser-images’ or file name is ‘browser.php’ which is the name of _this_ script – you don’t want people downloading these! (NB: ‘browser-images’ is where I stuck all the images relating to this app).

Most importantly, you need to declare this line:

define("DOWNLOAD_PATH", "/var/www/html/intranet/download");

This must be the ‘base’ path i.e. where you want to start browsing _from_ – users will not be able to browse _above_ this directory but they can browse anywhere within it (recursively).

To check this was working (and to ensure it would work independantly of Javascript) I ran this in the browser – wasn’t very pretty, wasn’t very usable but it was there and it would allow people without JS or the right DOM facilities to use the script.

Onward.

The DOM/Javascript/AJAX Script

This script needed to:

a) Connect to the PHP script above (hereafter referred to as ‘browser.php’) and call the right function to generate the right directory/file list for the directory that browser.php was currently ‘looking’ at.
b) Create animation to allow the file browser itself to appear and disappear as per user requirements.
c) Create a working ‘back’ button (also from the PHP script)
d) Degrade gracefully for those users who were Javascript or DOM-less.

My first issue was that I’d never used Javascript to animate movement before so I relied heavily on a code snippet of Jeremy Keith’s for that. His function allows you to pass in the values of the element you want to animate movement for, where on the x axis, where on the y axis and finally what the movement interval should be). The settings you may need to change are in these lines:

if(!hr.style.left){
  hr.style.left="-300px";
}
	
if(!hr.style.top){
  hr.style.top="70px";
}

Which you need to reflect the starting position of the selected element.

The rest of the code is fairly self explanatory and basically creates an AJAX connection to the PHP script and points the script to the ‘next’ directory and/or file. NB: You will need to specify the path to the file ‘browser.php’. There are three onclick events in this function too – one to browse the files, one to trigger the ‘back’ button and one to trigger the ‘home’ button.

The Stylesheet

The stylesheet is simplified (apologies for any redundancy in it – I think I stripped most of it out after testing but I may have missed the odd thing), but basically, the markup file contains a

with an id of ‘wrap’ to which I applied this style:

div#wrap {
  position: absolute;
  top: 73px;
  left: -300px;
  width: 1170px;
}

A quick glance back at the Javascript code reveals that I specified these are the starting points for my animation. What the animation will do therefore is scroll ‘wrap’ to the right, from its starting point at -300px (i.e. off the screen) and thus reveal it. The ‘close’ button will do the opposite.

You’ll also find all the styles I used for the HR File Browser itself.

The Markup

Finally, there is the markup. A standard XHTML page, its only wrinkle is the presence of two elements: firstly is the empty

with an id of ‘hrResponse’ – this is where I will ‘pipe’ all my dynamic content into. Secondly is the link element that starts the whole thing off:

<li><a title="Browse HR documents" id="openBrowser" href="http://localhost/intranet/download/browser.php">Browse HR documents</a></li>

as you can see the URI is not empty – it contains the path to the ‘browser.php’ file. This is to ensure graceful degradation. If the user has Javascript/DOM capabilities they will get the DOM scripted environment. If the don’t they’ll get sent to the ‘browser.php’ file with no enhancements.

And thats that. You can download it all from here – use it, improve it, distribute it – whatever you like.

On Using VAERS

14 Mar

Recently, KC posted a comment reflecting his strong suspicions that Dr Jim Laidler fabricated his infamous ‘incredible hulk’ report to VAERS:

You can’t backup Dr. Laidler’s…..VAERS bullshit with AutismWatch!

This is a common refrain. It’s been echoed by various people who choose to believe in the thiomersal/MMR/autism connection. Lets look again at what Jim Laidler said:

The chief problem with the VAERS data is that reports can be entered by anyone and are not routinely verified. To demonstrate this, a few years ago I entered a report that an influenza vaccine had turned me into The Hulk. The report was accepted and entered into the database.

This is what people routinely claim is ‘bullshit’. So, I thought I’d put it to the test.

VAERS has two ways of submitting a report. Firstly, you could download a PDF, fill it in and post it off. Or, you could do what I elected to do and fill in and submit a report online.

VAERS has a helpful popup which tells you exactly what it needs to know – which are the most important pieces of data it needs. However, the fact that I live in the UK was not deemed of importance. Neither was the fact that I told VAERS that my daughter had been turned into Wonder Woman. The only piece of contact data I submitted was my email address and I wasn’t even asked for that. I submitted it voluntarily.

I’m going to get a bit nerdy now.

VAERS use very, very simple Javascript form validation. It tripped me up a couple of times as I got confused about the fact you crazy Americans use mm/dd/yyyy rather than dd/mm/yyyy and it didn’t like the 24 hour clock either.

The Javascript routine caught the fact that I tried to submit an adverse event *before* the fictional date of my daughters birth but it failed to catch that I stated the vaccine was administered at 18months and that the date for vaccination I provided was only 6 months after the ‘birth’ date.

VAERS uses a ColdFusion backend. This means its easy to build a script that detects an incoming visitors IP address. It would therefore be just as easy to extend the script to use the IP address to determine what country the visitor is from. As it is, a UK resident has managed to successfully enter a record into VAERS.

But you don’t have to take my word for it, I ventured into Bartholomew Cubbins territory and recorded an AVI movie of me performing the whole process.

There’s a highly compressed and slightly lacking in quality version in SWF (Flash) format here (12mb) and a Hi-res version here (150mb). Please note that I use a ridiculously high resolution (1600 x 1200) so the SWF might encroach off the edge of your screens. If you’d rather download that file, right click it instead of left clicking it.

So what have I illustrated?

That Jim Laidler, far from ‘bullshitting’ about the record entry process and subsequent unreliablity of data was telling the truth. Anyone can enter any data into VAERS. Even someone from another country. Good source data? I think not.

Paul Shattock: What The…?

14 Mar

I recently had occasion to quote some of Mr Shattocks work. Namely, the case studies he diagnosed autism from in Victorian Britain. These were the papers that John Best Jr felt were lies. What I didn’t tell John until after he had a good rant and (if I recall) called the author ‘some nut’ was that Mr Shattock is a staunch believer in the MMR/Thiomersal/autism connection.

Some nut indeed.

Paul Shattock has extensive ties to Andrew Wakefield. Both feel that the MMR has some role to play in autism and Mr Shattock is a promoter of what he terms:

…some of the unorthodox forms of biomedical intervention currently being applied to autism.

Sunderland.

Dr Micheal Fitzpatrick comments:

Metabolic theories continued to attract a following in the shadowy area of alternative and fringe therapies, particularly in the USA. The cult of ‘orthomolecular psychiatry’ emerged out of these theories and popularised the treatment of a range of psychiatric problems with a high dose of vitamins, amino acids, minerals and other diets and dietary supplements. It is out of this tradition, which has little concern for the rigours of scientific research, that Mr Shattock’s studies have emerged.

Like the Geier’s, Paul Shattock publishes his research in some strange places (source as above):

It is impossible to evaluate Mr Shattock’s findings because they have not been published in any form. Indeed, virtually all his work has been published in the ‘grey literature’, in journals which have no formal process of evaluation or peer review.

It seems the paper he published and I quoted to John is a rare exception in a sea of vanity publishing. Indeed, Paul Shattocks Sunderland team website carries links to places like nomercury.org – hardly an informed or non-partisan choice.

Paul Shattock himself is an interesting figure. Father of an autistic child himself, he refuses to publish his work until he has studied 1,000 children. However that didn’t stop details of his work and preliminary findings mysteriously appearing (source as above):

Mr Shattock’s research entered the public realm, via journalists sympathetic to the anti-MMR campaign

But perhaps the greatest mystery about Paul Shattock is what the letters after his name mean. Sunday Times and Channel 4 Dispatches journalist Brian Deer asks the same question:

(I)….ran a Google search for DipAgVet, the latest qualification sported by Mr Paul Shattock, who specialises in urine tests.

For details of what came back and how you can help Mr Deer, go visit his site and take a guess.

Hating Sanity: My Very Own Sockpuppet

13 Mar

Someone (and its really not hard to guess who) has created a little sockpuppet site for me. Whomever (ahem) it is has also started sprinkling the blogosphere with spicy comments from ‘me’.

How cool is this? Someone (ahem) is worried enough about what I say to start a whole new blog to sockpuppet me!

I could get annoyed about such a thing but really, we have to look at it this way – I must be making a much bigger impression on someone (ahem) then I thought I was. Enough for them to be really worried about the success I’m having in getting through to people.

But lets not ruin the possible fun here. Lets have a bit of a Cluedo type blog post to work out the suspects….who is ‘kev’????

Is it:

a) JB Handley?

Evidence for: He’s got form for trying to coerce people to his beliefs. He’s also good for a bit of name-calling.
Evidence against: Probably knows I wouldn’t be anything but amused.

b) SueM?

Evidence for: Has the wit.
Evidence against: Lacks the motivation.

c) John Best Jr?

Evidence for? Has been repeatedly made to look foolish by a myriad of people on his own blog and other peoples but as I have adopted a position of purposefully getting in his face, I’ve probably stuck in his brain longer than most. Possibly because I continually post his racist (equates Muslims to terrorists), homophobic (believes homosexuality is a perversion which can be cured by a dose of ‘self-respect’) illogic (believes autism was invented by Eli Lilly in 1931) back in his face.

Lately I pointed out to Joseph that attempting rational debate with John was useless. His two crowning moments for me were when he said that there was no autism in China prior to 1999 (whereupon he was deluged with comments pointing to the many studies that predate 1990, let alone ’99 in China) and that autism didn’t exist before 1931 (whereupon I pointed out the diagnosis for case studies stretching back to the 1880’s) and it was at this point that I referred to him as ‘spectacularly stupid’ by which I meant that I was occasionally in literal awe of how stupid he truly was.

Evidence against: Can someone that stupid have a mildly amusing idea like this?

d) Sigourney Weaver?

Evidence for: Took umbrage at my post disagreeing with her statement that autism is a gift. Also annoyed that I confessed to lusting after Gillian Anderson and Geena Davis as well as her.

Evidence against: Is quite obviously in love with me.

So there we have it. Put on your deerstalkers, sniff your class A narcotic of choice, play the stringed instrument you like the best, indulge in a same sex relationship and claim its platonic, be insufferably condescending all the time and inspire lots of really good black and white movies starring Basil Rathbone.

Isabella Thomas Gets Her Day In Court

10 Mar

Isabella Thomas of the anti-vaccination group JABS has got her day in court.

She claims that the MMR jab,

led to her sons developing autism

in the careful phrasing of the BBC.

The proceedings will begin in June. It should be a very interesting case for all of us involved from whatever perspective we look at the MMR angle from. She also told the BBC that:

…she noticed he was experiencing difficulty shortly after he had the vaccine…..The infant’s condition gradually deteriorated from that moment onwards and he was eventually diagnosed with autism,” she said

A bit short on facts as an article, I decided to see if I could find out a bit more regarding this ‘gradual deterioration’ in terms of what form it took.

In November 2003, the then (and current) Lib Dem MP for Lewes (Ms. Thomas’ constituency) Norman Baker, presented a speech concerning Ms Thomas to the Health Minister (then Dr Reid if memory serves) in which he outlined her various issues with how her sons had been treated by the medical establishment. Her MP sums up:

My constituent believes, rightly or wrongly, that the reactions that have been caused in her children and which have led to these, it seems, permanent conditions are a result of MMR. She holds that view very strongly and communicates it to those in the health service. She feels that because she holds that view, her children are effectively being denied effective treatment to deal with their conditions until such time as she is prepared to deny that MMR is the cause. That may be a misconception on her part, but that is what she believes.

Mr Baker is obviously being as tactful to Ms Thomas’s belief system as he possibly can be which is commendable behaviour in an MP but I agree with his inference that its only because she holds the view that MMR ‘led to’ her sons autism that she feels she’s having treatment withheld for _that_ condition (not autism, but MMR induced autism).

More interestingly, he also details her sons ‘gradual deterioration’. This is a description of Michael, her eldest.:

…he was like a wild animal; he screamed when anyone touched him and cried day and night. He has been diagnosed with regressive autism and has an obsessive-compulsive disorder. He suffers from auditory hallucinations, increased clumsiness, chronic bowel disease, temperature control problems, severe headaches, loss of memory, breathing problems and rashes.

And Terry, Michael’s younger brother:

During the night after the vaccination, Terry suffered a fit and within a week he developed excessive temperature swings and loss of skills. Before the vaccination, he was potty trained, but he regressed the very next day. Within two weeks he began to suffer from constipation and chronic diarrhoea. Within a month he appeared clumsy and walked into doors. He stopped talking and would become completely silent. He no longer indulged in pretend play. He now suffers from fits, jaundice when ill, chronic bowel disease, very high fevers, rashes, regressive autism and excessive thirst.

Both boys are said to have:

the measles virus, consistent with the vaccine strain

found in their bowels and blood in Michaels case.

As far as I read it, *none* of Michaels symptoms match those of any known diagnostic criteria of autism. Two, maybe three out of the eight listed above match comorbidities sometimes associated with autism.

Terry’s symptom list is more intriguing and contains the hotly debated ‘regressive autism’. It also lists it _as_ a symptom, indicating that the other symptoms haven’t _caused_ it but exist alongside it. If we take the other as possible indicators of autism then only one ‘he no longer indulged in pretend play’ speaks openly of autism to me. Again, two, possibly three of his listed symptoms out of the thirteen or so listed speak of sometime comorbidities.

Its an established fact that vaccines can cause injury. Could they have caused these injuries? Of course they _could_ . But did they? I don’t know. I would imagine that Ms Thomas filled out a form for the Vaccine Damage Payment Unit and I would imagine that, as in all cases, they performed an investigation and found her claim unsubstantiated. I could be wrong though, maybe she didn’t but seeing as JABS link to the VDPU and encourage people to make such a claim it would seem logical to assume she has. if they rejected her claim that means they don’t agree that the MMR jab caused either of kids problems.

But lets say they did, just to play devils advocate. As the listed symptoms seem utterly dissimilar to those used to diagnose autism I’m unsure how Ms Thomas hopes to establish a causative link at all. Should be an interesting case to watch all the same.

Fire Cannot Burn Truth

9 Mar

Something of a departure in a way, I want to talk today about something that blogging friend Orac is talking about today, namely that a bunch of arsonists have burnt down the office of the Holocaust History Project in an apparent attempt to stifle the work that goes on there.

The HHP is a vital cog in the machinery that fights against the neo-fascist perpetuated denial of the Holocaust. It puts out educational material to schools in the US designed to educated about the nature and effects of the holocaust.

The Nazi regime is estimated to have murdered approx 275,000 disabled people during its reign, reasoning that:

It was argued that allowing disabled people to live and have children, led to the “unfit” reproducing more quickly than “the fit”. It was said that this weakened society’s ability to function efficiently, placing an unnecessary toll on non-disabled people.

I’ll leave you to reflect on how disconcertingly familiar that sounds to some sentiments repeated today by a certain section of people.

On the grounds that disabled people were less worthwhile and an unfair burden on society, a widespread and compulsory sterilisation program took place. This began in 1933…..sterilisation was followed by an active killing program, which started in 1939

Under a secret plan called the ‘T4 Program’ (T4 was a reference to the address of the program’s Berlin HQ – Tiergartenstrasse 4), disabled people in Germany were killed by lethal injection or poison gas. The T4 Program saw a string of six death camps – called “euthanasia centres” – set up across Germany and Austria. These centres contained gassing installations designed to look like shower stalls.

This is why organisations like the Holocaust History Project are vital. If we are ever to learn from the mistakes of the past we cannot allow the ignorant and brutal to hold sway.

Burden Of Proof

8 Mar

As one dives ever deeper into the science (or lack thereof) between the two camps of the autism/thimerosal debate, the questions become more and more interesting.

It occurred to me awhile ago to wonder how, if we agree that thiomersal in vaccines causes autism, the UK and the US have such very similar rates of autism but very dissimilar rates of thiomersal. The main stance I’m challenging (as ever) is that of Generation Rescue who make it clear they believe thiomersal to be the main culprit (60% of the ‘mercury facts’ page is devoted to thiomersal related questions and thiomersal has its own dedicated section on the GR site). Lets have a look at mercury intake at the height of both countries thiiomersal use:

UK
..a substantial proportion of children in the GPRD cohort will have had a cumulative Hg exposure of *75 µg* of Hg.

US
the maximum cumulative exposure in some US children was *187.5 µg* Hg.

Source

Thats quite some disparity. It raises a few questions almost immediately.

Firstly, are US children more ‘severely’ autistic than UK children? If not, why not? Surely if they’ve received more than twice what UK kids have via vaccines we should see vastly more severely (or low functioning, pick your pejorative) affected autistic people. Is there any evidence this is the case? Well, if IQ is anything to go by (which I fully accept is questionable and I’m only using because thats how the diagnostic criteria work) then the latest stats as quoted by Joseph indicate it is not the case:

Why is the prevalence of CDDS clients without mental retardation (presumably based on IQ testing) going up quickly?

Joseph.

Are there any other indicators that ‘full’ or ‘classic’ or ‘kanners’ or ‘full spectrum’ or ‘low functioning’ (again pick your pejorative) autism is increasing in the US compared to the UK at a ratio of 2:1 whilst ‘high functioning’ or ‘Aspergers Syndrome’ cases are not? I can’t think of any.

Secondly, where are all the dead autistic US children compared to still living UK children?

We hear all the time that autistic people are poor excretors of mercury and yet I find it incredible that given this supposed poor excretion, American autistic kids aren’t dying much earlier than their UK counterparts. Isn’t mercury ingestion eventually fatal? At what level is it necessary for someone to excrete mercury in order to maintain life? There seems to be no evidence to suggest more autistic people die from illnesses close in appearance to fatal mercury exposure than non-autistics and yet not only do they have this inability to excrete mercury, they have a huge mercury burden to start life with and exactly the same exposure to other forms of environmental mercury as non-autistics.

And the inverse is also true. If we accept by virtue of the fact that autistic people are not dying of mercury poisoning that they *must* be excreting it then why do their symptoms not improve? According to proponents of chelation, chelation not only removes the mercury it actually recovers/cures the patient. Is there some aspect to chelation that there isn’t to normal excretion paths? How does chelation reverse the alleged neuro damage when ordinary excretion apparently cannot?

No answers here, only questions.